Skip to main content

Guidelines for Teaching about Religion in K-12 Public Schools & the Kentucky Faith and Public History Education Project

By Lesley Barker PhD

There is no law that prohibits a public school teacher from teaching about religion. In fact, in 1963, Supreme Court Justice Tom Clark wrote this opinion:

“A person cannot be fully educated without understanding the role of religion in history, culture and politics…The law, constitutional or otherwise, is no impediment to the realization of that aim.[1]”

The confusion comes because of the First Amendment and what has been come to be called the “Establishment Clause”:

 “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof[2]”.

Because the public schools are government funded, municipal institutions, this American freedom and right to worship whom, when and, indeed, whether cannot be controlled, required or manipulated by the school or by the teachers. There have been many over-reaches that have attempted to remove all mention of religion, and many would say of the Christian religion in particular, from the public school classroom since the 1962 Supreme Court decisions to take prayer and Bible reading out of the public schools. This has led to a wide-spread illiteracy in America regarding religion. It has been exacerbated, perhaps, by the fact that religious studies scholars have not been asked to collaborate to form content and skill guidelines for the teaching of religion in public schools in spite of the fact that religion is “embedded in curriculum standards across disciplines, especially in social studies and English”[3]

To address the issues and to combat its assessment that illiteracy about religion “fuels prejudice and antagonism”[4], in 2010, the American Academy of Religion produced a document[5] that carefully dissects what can and cannot be taught in the public schools. The executive summary of this report provides a quick set of words that should guide teachers when speaking of religion. Instruction about religion should promote awareness, not acceptance of any religion. Lessons should be direct students to study about but not practice any religion. Teaching objectives should be to expose students to diverse religious views without imposing any one view so that students become educated about all religions while the teacher neither promotes nor “denigrates” any. The report is written for teachers using very accessible language and it provides practical information to show why we should teach about religion, the legal issues involved, how to do it and how to become competent to do it. It is accessible online for free using the link in the footnotes. Every teacher would benefit from reading it.

This blog is also committed to assisting teachers to provide secular, non-devotional instruction about the Christian religion. The Kentucky Faith and Public History Education Project features information about Christianity as a resource for teachers and public school students. Christianity in American is increasingly diverse and the boundaries between Christian practice and understanding have become increasingly blurred and, even ugly, because of its entanglements with our modern politics. We are committed to provide information about how Christianity is embedded in Kentucky’s history and culture and how Christian Kentuckians have impacted the community at large. Some may critique this blog and this project for too narrow a focus saying that we should provide equivalent information about other religions that are practiced in Kentucky. Our response is that our expertise is around the Christian religion. We stand as a resource for teachers, as a field trip option to explore the early nineteenth century camp meetings that triggered the Second Great Awakening in American and informed the conscience of antebellum America. That is a complex, nuanced and important topic with significance for the entire nation as far as the study of humanities is concerned.


[1] Charles C. Hayes, Oliver Thomas. Common Ground: A First Amendment Guide to Religion and Public Schools. 2007. First Amendment Center.

[2] United States Constitution. Bill of Rights. First Amendment

[3] Moore, Diane L, Chair. Guidelines for Teaching About Religion in K-12 Public Schools in the United States. 2010. American Academy of Religion. ONLINE. Accessed 10/9/2020. https://www.aarweb.org/common/Uploaded%20files/Publications%20and%20News/Guides%20and%20Best%20Practices/AARK-12CurriculumGuidelinesPDF.pdf

[4] Ibid.

[5] Ibid.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Why Teach about Kentucky's Early Nineteenth Century Camp Meetings

  Over the next several weeks, this blog will feature posts about the early nineteenth century camp meetings such as the Cane Ridge Revival [1] in Bourbon County Kentucky which happened in August 1801. It was organized and promoted over several months as a Presbyterian celebration of Holy Communion. While Holy Communion remains a very important ordinance in every modern Christian denomination and church, it is usually embedded in a regular congregational meeting, taking no more than about 30 minutes. This was not the case with eighteenth and early nineteenth century Presbyterians. Consistent with the traditions brought to the United States by Scottish Presbyterians, Communion took at least three days. First the prospective participants were required to prove that they were spiritually qualified to receive the bread and wine that represented the body and blood of Jesus Christ. The next day was for the actual sacramental meal. The third day was given to praise and thanks to God for what
Post a Comment
Read more

Arbor Day STEAM (tree) Field Trip for 1st through 3rd Grades Friday, April 28, 2023

  Arbor Day is Friday, April 28, 2023. We're opening the Walking Trail and Arboretum for first, second and third grade classes to come for a 40-minute outdoor STEAM adventure featuring trees. Your students will hear and read poems about trees. They will learn to identify the parts of a tree and count tree rings to figure out how old a tree was when it was cut down. The experience involves a half-mile walk on a gravel trail through a beautiful arboretum at 616 Clintonville Road in Paris, Kentucky. We are charging $2/person. Use this link to select when your group will come and to help us have enough tree cookies on hand. A spacious picnic area is available for your class to use if you want to bring brown-bag lunches. Some souvenirs: books, candy, and trading cards are for sale if your class brings spending money. Please use this link to register your class and to select the time you will come. 
Post a Comment
Read more

First lessons about world religion for primary classes

Religion is lumped in with history, literature, languages and art as one of the humanities but we tend not to feel as comfortable teaching about religion as the other subjects. Teaching about religion does not promote any one particular faith. It introduces the fact that there are differences between people and their ideas and practices about God. Primary students can easily be introduced to the idea that there are different religions during social studies units about the community and its people. Different religions use different types of  buildings. Different religions can be identified by the way some adherents dress. When you are teaching about communities, say that people worship in different types of buildings. People who are Christians worship in churches or cathedrals. People who are Jewish worship in synagogues. People who are Muslim worship in mosques, and people who are Hindu or Buddhist worship in temples. Take pictures of any of these buildings in your school community and
Post a Comment
Read more